something interesting

<  BACK TO Mr. Markets

A Little Perspective Please

Retail traders hunting the Holy Grail

‍The other day I was invited to speak to a retail trading seminar about the “Role of banks in the FX market in the 21st Century”.

For me, the title of the talk was presumptuous given that without banks there would be no FX market.

I talked about the way that banks provide liquidity but have, rightly, decided that the retail trading market is best left to fintech experts who can get closer to their clients and comply with very specific regulation.

Since LTCM and sub-prime, banks have more than enough new regulation to cope with just handling existing operations. A further consideration is that banks are faced with trying to gain market share in liquidity provision, realizing that economy of scale is all that matters, yet having to provide ultra-fine pricing to Payment and Remittance” businesses that are taking away their market share.

The talk went well but it was in the question and answer session that followed that things got interesting. Almost from the first question I felt I was in a very hostile environment. The attitude of retail traders to banks is to universally see them as the enemy.

“They hunt out our Stops”

It is human nature to blame someone else when something goes wrong. My audience was, presumably, made up of a fair cross section of experience and success.

Thankfully, I left “mainstream” trading before retail trading took hold so I could speak from a neutral standpoint. The FX market, at the last count, was $5trn per day across all products. That number is growing but suffered a small setback from 2013 when it was at $5.3trn.

The retail trading market makes up about 3.5% or $175bio of that trade. The $175bio is made up of spot and swaps. It is estimated that spot trading is about $85bio.

So, retail trading makes up about 1.7% of daily turnover.

Banks are seen as the enemy because they don’t “comply”. Yes, it may appear that they are hunting out stops and generally ruining the market for the “little guy” but that is definitely not their intention. There was an undercurrent of mumbled disagreement so I needed empirical evidence. I asked a question. “How many of you use a technical analysis tool like MACD to set your stop loss?”. Around 70% of the hands were raised. So, what is more likely, I asked, that your signal places your stop at a critical level where banks traders using other methods of trading see a possible development, or that same nasty trader is trying to screw you to possibly make a few dollars?

There is a real need to be more creative when placing stop losses. I know it is an admittance of defeat to place more emphasis on a stop loss but it is better to lose the battle and live to fight another day.

They change the spread.

This is my favorite topic when talking to retail traders either individually or as a group.

Spread is the magic word used by “some” brokers to entice business. Spread doesn’t matter. It’s price that matters. If I am looking to sell Eur/Usd and I get made prices of 31/33 and 29/30 I will sell at 31 since that is the best bid. That is obvious I know but illustrates perfectly the issue.

Slippage on stop loss orders is another thorny issue but there really is no need in a major pair or cross for stops to be filled at a level significantly worse than the order.

The universe of “certain brokers” is driven by a numbers game and retention simply means retain until drained.

Banks rarely change their spread. They have no need to but they frequently change the price. Again, blame the tech guy who created the algo not the trader whose role has been changed out of all recognition since the whole tech revolution reached into his world.

I managed to escape with both my dignity and my ideas intact and, hopefully, altered some preconceptions about “the enemy”.

Retail traders hunting the Holy Grail

‍The other day I was invited to speak to a retail trading seminar about the “Role of banks in the FX market in the 21st Century”.

For me, the title of the talk was presumptuous given that without banks there would be no FX market.

I talked about the way that banks provide liquidity but have, rightly, decided that the retail trading market is best left to fintech experts who can get closer to their clients and comply with very specific regulation.

Since LTCM and sub-prime, banks have more than enough new regulation to cope with just handling existing operations. A further consideration is that banks are faced with trying to gain market share in liquidity provision, realizing that economy of scale is all that matters, yet having to provide ultra-fine pricing to Payment and Remittance” businesses that are taking away their market share.

The talk went well but it was in the question and answer session that followed that things got interesting. Almost from the first question I felt I was in a very hostile environment. The attitude of retail traders to banks is to universally see them as the enemy.

“They hunt out our Stops”

It is human nature to blame someone else when something goes wrong. My audience was, presumably, made up of a fair cross section of experience and success.

Thankfully, I left “mainstream” trading before retail trading took hold so I could speak from a neutral standpoint. The FX market, at the last count, was $5trn per day across all products. That number is growing but suffered a small setback from 2013 when it was at $5.3trn.

The retail trading market makes up about 3.5% or $175bio of that trade. The $175bio is made up of spot and swaps. It is estimated that spot trading is about $85bio.

So, retail trading makes up about 1.7% of daily turnover.

Banks are seen as the enemy because they don’t “comply”. Yes, it may appear that they are hunting out stops and generally ruining the market for the “little guy” but that is definitely not their intention. There was an undercurrent of mumbled disagreement so I needed empirical evidence. I asked a question. “How many of you use a technical analysis tool like MACD to set your stop loss?”. Around 70% of the hands were raised. So, what is more likely, I asked, that your signal places your stop at a critical level where banks traders using other methods of trading see a possible development, or that same nasty trader is trying to screw you to possibly make a few dollars?

There is a real need to be more creative when placing stop losses. I know it is an admittance of defeat to place more emphasis on a stop loss but it is better to lose the battle and live to fight another day.

They change the spread.

This is my favorite topic when talking to retail traders either individually or as a group.

Spread is the magic word used by “some” brokers to entice business. Spread doesn’t matter. It’s price that matters. If I am looking to sell Eur/Usd and I get made prices of 31/33 and 29/30 I will sell at 31 since that is the best bid. That is obvious I know but illustrates perfectly the issue.

Slippage on stop loss orders is another thorny issue but there really is no need in a major pair or cross for stops to be filled at a level significantly worse than the order.

The universe of “certain brokers” is driven by a numbers game and retention simply means retain until drained.

Banks rarely change their spread. They have no need to but they frequently change the price. Again, blame the tech guy who created the algo not the trader whose role has been changed out of all recognition since the whole tech revolution reached into his world.

I managed to escape with both my dignity and my ideas intact and, hopefully, altered some preconceptions about “the enemy”.

lastest Articles

Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Let the debates begin!
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Bitcoin Price Prediction: BTC slips into “Buy the Dip” Zone
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold: Eyes on August lows of $1863 ahead of US PMIs and round two Powell
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: US dollar’s haven demand in vogue ahead of a busy day
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold remains on track to test the August low of $1863
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Forecast: Bears now eyeing a sustained break below 1.1700 mark
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar buoyant ahead of Powell, UK PM Johnson’s COBRA meeting eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold Futures: Still room for extra gains
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Forecast: Further consolidation looks likely ahead of Fed speakers
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: US dollar sags amid fiscal overhang, mounting coronavirus risks
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – No ease up for Powell
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
BOE Quick Analysis: Bailey blasts sterling with specter of negative rates, why more falls are likely
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB’s De Guindos: Euro exchange rate is fundamental for inflation
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Fed drives dollar higher, gold and stocks lower, BOE, jobless claims eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold aims $1980 as focus shifts to Wednesday’s FOMC
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
GBP/USD to surge to 1.40 by September-2021 – UBS
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Upbeat Chinese data boosts mood, Boris' bill passes first hurdle, Gold shines
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – More stimulus on the way?
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB's Lane: Euro's rise dampens inflation outlook
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: King dollar holds the rein amid cautious optimism, eyes on US CPI
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Forecast: Euro set to fall? ECB expectations may be overconfident
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Brexit in deep crisis, vaccine hopes resurface, all eyes on the ECB
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Brent Oil resumes its core bear trend
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB’s Muller: A timely exit from temporary emergency measures is important
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Vaccine trial halt exacerbates risk off mood, Brexit, BOC, and US fiscal talks eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold Price Analysis: XAU/USD drops further and approaches $1,900/oz
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Bitcoin Price Update: BTC bulls ready to strike back once $11,000 is cleared
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Hard-Brexit fears pound the Pound, Dollar bid on US-Sino woes
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD risks deeper pullback as 1.20 peak looks far
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold Price Analysis: Downside appears more compelling while below $1946 – Confluence Detector
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar stabilizes in the NFP aftermath, Oil tumbles amid holiday-thinned trading
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead - Trump Closing the Gap
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Nonfarm Payrolls Preview: Fed’s policy shift to introduce vital noise
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold rebounds from weekly lows, turns neutral around $1945 region
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD trims losses and regains 1.1850 post-US ISM
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Fed's Williams: Policymakers seek inflation that targets 2% over time
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Bitcoin Cash Market Update: BCH fork is inevitable as Bitcoin ABC team separates from the project
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar climbs back from the abyss, ADP NFP, Fed speakers awaited
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Bring on the Jobs Report
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Jackson Hole Goes Virtual
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead - The focus remains on COVID-19, the Fed and Congress
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Gold up, dollar down amid stalled fiscal talks, vaccine hopes, ahead of jobless claims
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead- Is the economic recovery stalling?
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar licking its wounds, gold gives ground, ahead of the all-important Fed decision
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – What more can the Fed do?
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Bitcoin Market Update: BTC/USD hits a pause button before another bullish assault
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Price Analysis: Potential correction ahead of further gains
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: China's payback weighs on markets, boosts dollar, PMIs, coronavirus figures eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
GBP/USD: Technicals show bulls have the upper hand
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold: Correction in sight after reaching nine-year highs
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar licking its wounds, gold shines, US coronavirus cases eyed after Trump's U-turn
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold jumps to fresh multi-year tops, beyond $1820 level
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: EUR/USD sells the fact, Gold looking strong, Trump's coronavirus briefs make comeback
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Bitcoin Market Update: BTC fails to live up to the status of digital gold
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
S&P 500 Futures Price Analysis: Bears retain control after rejection at falling trendline resistance
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: EU leaders can’t reach an agreement on the EU rescue fund
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Focus remains on Virus Spread, Fiscal Stimulus, Rebounding data, and Earnings
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD continues to look at the 1.1495 March high
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
AUD/USD to remain resilient in the near-term
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar dominates ahead of EU Summit, updated look at the US consumer amid rising cases
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold probes multi-day lows around $1,790/oz
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Price Analysis: A test of 1.1420 appears closer
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: US dollar seizes control as risk aversion returns, a busy docket ahead
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold to stay above $1800 fueled by lower real rates
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB expected to keep rates unchanged
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Vaccine, earnings optimism downs the dollar; eyes on COVID-19 stats, BOE’s Bailey
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Bring on Earnings Season
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Crude Oil Futures: Upside looks limited
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB’s Lagarde: Economic recovery would be constrained, uncertain and fragmented
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Gold eyeing $1,800, dollar mixed, as coronavirus, Hong Kong peg move markets
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold Price Analysis: Holds steady above $1775 level, bullish bias remains
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
BOJ to project economic recovery in report next week – Reuters
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Chinese optimism downs dollar as investors ignore US coronavirus, data eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Economic Reopening Continues
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Stocks' strength, dollar downing face Non-Farm Payrolls test as Trump endorses masks
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
BoE's Haskel: Activity appears to be coming back faster than anticipated
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Company News
GBP Bank Account
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Gold shines, markets look for direction after a successful Q2, ahead of busy start to Q3
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold eases below $1770 level, downside seems limited
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD: Europe fights coronavirus and stuns the dollar
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Markets attempt to shrug off grim coronavirus developments
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Jitters Continue into Busy Week
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
US Dollar Index clings to gains near 97.50 ahead of data
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB’s Lagarde: Economic recovery will be a complicated matter
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold sticks to the positive outlook
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Price Analysis: Focus now shifted to 1.1170
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar dominates, gold shines as coronavirus rages in the US, triple data release eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD Price Analysis: Rising bets for a test of 1.1400 and beyond
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
EUR/USD recedes from tops above 1.1300
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold: Falling US Real Yields fuels bull trend towards new highs at $1921 – Credit Suisse
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Risk rides the Navarro rollercoaster, Eurozone/ UK PMIs, virus stats in focus
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
BoE is seen increasing further the size of QE – UOB
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Risk-recovery back in play, US dollar recedes with second-wave virus fears
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Week Ahead – Markets play tug-of-war with Covid-19 concerns and reopening momentum
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Coronavirus, weak data outweigh reopening optimism, BOE, jobless claims eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
ECB's de Guindos: Better if EU aid is distributed via grants rather than loans
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold Price Analysis: XAU/USD slumps toward $1,710 on improving risk sentiment
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Dollar up as health, geopolitics replace consumer optimism, Powell, COVID-19 data eyed
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Gold clings to modest daily gains, around $1730 area
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613
Market Analysis
Forex Today: Double stimulus talk downs dollar ahead of Powell's power-play, US retail sales
https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/b23a9c274f4a28b6ab7acddb98b80613